Reorder LADSPA fx mixing

This PR moves mixing of LADSPA effects in fluid_rvoice_mixer_process_fx() before mixing of the internal reverb and chorus effects.

Currently, if a user sets synth.audio-groups >1, LADSPA effects can be applied to specific MIDI channels only. The user can then follow @mawe42's great suggestion from the mailing list and use a zero-gain amp effect to mix the LADSPA buffers back to the first host port for output to the sound card (This seems like the most proper way to do this IMO - the LADSPA subsystem shouldn't have to figure out what FluidSynth's audio output channels are on its own).

However, since the internal reverb and chorus are applied first and don't care about synth.audio-groups, the LADSPA effects will appear in the internal effects buffers regardless of which audio_group the currently-playing MIDI channels are part of. Increasing synth.effects-groups is not ideal since it adds a lot of processing load, and also would seem to require that effects-groups always be equal to audio-groups. A user could disable the internal reverb and chorus and add them as LADSPA effects, but it's nice to be able to have backing instruments or tracks from MIDI files play "normally" (i.e. according to the soundfonts' reverb and chorus settings), while a user plays lead with interesting effects that don't alter the backing voices.

Resolves #1117.
This commit is contained in:
Bill Peterson 2022-06-18 14:08:00 -05:00 committed by derselbst
parent 24898c126d
commit 57554ee35a
2 changed files with 13 additions and 13 deletions

View File

@ -509,8 +509,8 @@ int fluid_ladspa_reset(fluid_ladspa_fx_t *fx)
* @param block_count number of blocks to render * @param block_count number of blocks to render
* @param block_size number of samples in a block * @param block_size number of samples in a block
* *
* FluidSynth calls this function during main output mixing, just after * FluidSynth calls this function during main output mixing,
* the internal reverb and chorus effects have been processed. * just before processing the internal reverb and chorus effects.
* *
* It copies audio data from the supplied buffers, runs all effects and copies the * It copies audio data from the supplied buffers, runs all effects and copies the
* resulting audio back into the same buffers. * resulting audio back into the same buffers.

View File

@ -150,6 +150,17 @@ fluid_rvoice_mixer_process_fx(fluid_rvoice_mixer_t *mixer, int current_blockcoun
fluid_profile_ref_var(prof_ref); fluid_profile_ref_var(prof_ref);
#ifdef LADSPA
/* Run the signal through the LADSPA Fx unit. The buffers have already been
* set up in fluid_rvoice_mixer_set_ladspa. */
if(mixer->ladspa_fx)
{
fluid_ladspa_run(mixer->ladspa_fx, current_blockcount, FLUID_BUFSIZE);
fluid_check_fpe("LADSPA");
}
#endif
if(mix_fx_to_out) if(mix_fx_to_out)
{ {
@ -238,17 +249,6 @@ fluid_rvoice_mixer_process_fx(fluid_rvoice_mixer_t *mixer, int current_blockcoun
current_blockcount * FLUID_BUFSIZE); current_blockcount * FLUID_BUFSIZE);
} }
#ifdef LADSPA
/* Run the signal through the LADSPA Fx unit. The buffers have already been
* set up in fluid_rvoice_mixer_set_ladspa. */
if(mixer->ladspa_fx)
{
fluid_ladspa_run(mixer->ladspa_fx, current_blockcount, FLUID_BUFSIZE);
fluid_check_fpe("LADSPA");
}
#endif
} }
/** /**