diff --git a/src/m_menu.c b/src/m_menu.c
index 20aec7a01..c7f9fb66f 100644
--- a/src/m_menu.c
+++ b/src/m_menu.c
@@ -10091,10 +10091,10 @@ static void M_DrawSetupMultiPlayerMenu(void)
 
 	// draw skin string
 	V_DrawRightAlignedString(BASEVIDWIDTH - x, y,
-	             ((MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status & IT_TYPE) == IT_SPACE ? V_TRANSLUCENT : 0)|(itemOn == 1 ? V_YELLOWMAP : 0)|V_ALLOWLOWERCASE,
+	             ((MP_PlayerSetupMenu[1].status & IT_TYPE) == IT_SPACE ? V_TRANSLUCENT : 0)|(itemOn == 1 ? V_YELLOWMAP : 0)|V_ALLOWLOWERCASE,
 	             skins[setupm_fakeskin].realname);
 
-	if (itemOn == 1 && (MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status & IT_TYPE) != IT_SPACE)
+	if (itemOn == 1 && (MP_PlayerSetupMenu[1].status & IT_TYPE) != IT_SPACE)
 	{
 		V_DrawCharacter(BASEVIDWIDTH - x - 10 - V_StringWidth(skins[setupm_fakeskin].realname, V_ALLOWLOWERCASE) - (skullAnimCounter/5), y,
 			'\x1C' | V_YELLOWMAP, false);
@@ -10168,7 +10168,7 @@ colordraw:
 
 	// draw color string
 	V_DrawRightAlignedString(BASEVIDWIDTH - x, y,
-	             (itemOn == 2 ? V_YELLOWMAP : 0)|V_ALLOWLOWERCASE,
+	             ((MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status & IT_TYPE) == IT_SPACE ? V_TRANSLUCENT : 0)|(itemOn == 2 ? V_YELLOWMAP : 0)|V_ALLOWLOWERCASE,
 	             Color_Names[setupm_fakecolor]);
 
 	if (itemOn == 2 && (MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status & IT_TYPE) != IT_SPACE)
@@ -10388,6 +10388,12 @@ static void M_SetupMultiPlayer(INT32 choice)
 	else
 		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[1].status = (IT_KEYHANDLER|IT_STRING);
 
+	// ditto with colour
+	if (Playing() && G_GametypeHasTeams())
+		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status = (IT_GRAYEDOUT);
+	else
+		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status = (IT_KEYHANDLER|IT_STRING);
+
 	multi_spr2 = P_GetSkinSprite2(&skins[setupm_fakeskin], SPR2_WALK, NULL);
 
 	MP_PlayerSetupDef.prevMenu = currentMenu;
@@ -10424,6 +10430,12 @@ static void M_SetupMultiPlayer2(INT32 choice)
 	else
 		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[1].status = (IT_KEYHANDLER | IT_STRING);
 
+	// ditto with colour
+	if (Playing() && G_GametypeHasTeams())
+		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status = (IT_GRAYEDOUT);
+	else
+		MP_PlayerSetupMenu[2].status = (IT_KEYHANDLER|IT_STRING);
+
 	multi_spr2 = P_GetSkinSprite2(&skins[setupm_fakeskin], SPR2_WALK, NULL);
 
 	MP_PlayerSetupDef.prevMenu = currentMenu;