libs-base/Source/NSHTTPCookie.m

/* Implementation for NSHTTPCookie for GNUstep
   Copyright (C) 2006 Software Foundation, Inc.

   Written by:  Richard Frith-Macdonald <rfm@gnu.org>
   Date: 2006
   
   This file is part of the GNUstep Base Library.

   This library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
   modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
   License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
   version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
   
   This library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
   but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
   MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU
   Library General Public License for more details.
   
   You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
   License along with this library; if not, write to the Free
   Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin Street, Fifth Floor,
   Boston, MA 02111 USA.
   */ 

/* 
  Try to handle cookies via the original Netscape specification
  (http://web.archive.org/web/20070805052634/http://wp.netscape.com/newsref/std/cookie_spec.html)
  and the official RFC2965 (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2965).

  Header fields named "Set-Cookie" are processed using either the original
  spec or RFC2965. "Set-Cookie2" fields use the RFC spec. There are some 
  crazy things to be aware of though. Multiple cookies can be specified in the
  same header and are separated by a comma. However, cookies themselves can
  also contain commas, most notably in the Expires field (which is not quoted
  and can contain spaces as well). The last key/value does not have to have a
  semi-colon, so this can be tricky to parse if another cookie occurs
  after this (See GSRangeOfCookie).
*/

#import "common.h"
#define	EXPOSE_NSHTTPCookie_IVARS	1
#import "GSURLPrivate.h"
#import "Foundation/NSSet.h"
#import "Foundation/NSValue.h"
#import "Foundation/NSString.h"
#import "Foundation/NSCalendarDate.h"
#import "GNUstepBase/Unicode.h"

NSString * const NSHTTPCookieComment = @"Comment";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieCommentURL = @"CommentURL";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieDiscard = @"Discard";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieDomain = @"Domain";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieExpires = @"Expires";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieMaximumAge = @"MaximumAge";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieName = @"Name";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieOriginURL = @"OriginURL";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookiePath = @"Path";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookiePort = @"Port";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieSecure = @"Secure";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieValue = @"Value";
NSString * const NSHTTPCookieVersion = @"Version";
static NSString * const HTTPCookieHTTPOnly = @"HTTPOnly";

// Internal data storage
typedef struct {
  NSDictionary	*_properties;
} Internal;
 
#define	this	((Internal*)(self->_NSHTTPCookieInternal))
#define	inst	((Internal*)(o->_NSHTTPCookieInternal))

/* Bitmap of characters considered white space if in an old style property
 * list. This is the same as the set given by the isspace() function in the
 * POSIX locale, but (for cross-locale portability of property list files)
 * is fixed, rather than locale dependent.
 */
static const unsigned char whitespace[32] = {
  '\x00',
  '\x3f',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x01',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
  '\x00',
};

#define IS_BIT_SET(a,i) ((((a) & (1<<(i)))) > 0)

#define GS_IS_WHITESPACE(X) IS_BIT_SET(whitespace[(X)/8], (X) % 8)

static id GSPropertyListFromCookieFormat(NSString *string, int version);
static NSRange GSRangeOfCookie(NSString *string);

@implementation NSHTTPCookie

+ (id) allocWithZone: (NSZone*)z
{
  NSHTTPCookie	*o = [super allocWithZone: z];

  if (o != nil)
    {
      o->_NSHTTPCookieInternal = NSZoneCalloc(z, 1, sizeof(Internal));
    }
  return o;
}

+ (id) cookieWithProperties: (NSDictionary *)properties
{
  NSHTTPCookie	*o;

  o = [[self alloc] initWithProperties: properties];
  return AUTORELEASE(o);
}

+ (NSMutableArray *) _parseField: (NSString *)field 
		       forHeader: (NSString *)header
			  andURL: (NSURL *)url
{
  int version;
  NSString *defaultPath, *defaultDomain;
  NSMutableArray *a;

  if ([header isEqual: @"Set-Cookie"])
    version = 0;
  else if ([header isEqual: @"Set-Cookie2"])
    version = 1;
  else
    return nil;

  a = [NSMutableArray array];
  defaultDomain = [url host];
  defaultPath = [url path];
  if ([[url absoluteString] hasSuffix: @"/"] == NO)
    defaultPath = [defaultPath stringByDeletingLastPathComponent];

  /* We could use an NSScanner here, but this string could contain all
     sorts of odd stuff. It's not quite a property list either - it has
     dates and also could have tokens without values. */
  while (1)
    {
      NSHTTPCookie *cookie;
      NSMutableDictionary *dict;
      NSString *onecookie;
      NSRange range = GSRangeOfCookie(field);

      if (range.location == NSNotFound)
	break;
      onecookie = [field substringWithRange: range];
      NS_DURING
	dict = GSPropertyListFromCookieFormat(onecookie, version);
      NS_HANDLER
	dict = nil;
      NS_ENDHANDLER
      if ([dict count])
	{
	  if ([dict objectForKey: NSHTTPCookiePath] == nil)
	    [dict setObject: defaultPath forKey: NSHTTPCookiePath];
	  if ([dict objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieDomain] == nil)
	    [dict setObject: defaultDomain forKey: NSHTTPCookieDomain];
	  cookie = [NSHTTPCookie cookieWithProperties: dict];
	  if (cookie)
	    [a addObject: cookie];
	}
      if ([field length] <= NSMaxRange(range))
	break;
      field = [field substringFromIndex: NSMaxRange(range)+1];
    }
  return a;
}

+ (NSArray *) cookiesWithResponseHeaderFields: (NSDictionary *)headerFields
				       forURL: (NSURL *)URL
{
  NSEnumerator   *henum = [headerFields keyEnumerator];
  NSMutableArray *a = [NSMutableArray array];
  NSString *header;

  while ((header = [henum nextObject]))
    {
      NSMutableArray *suba 
	= [self _parseField: [headerFields objectForKey: header] 
		forHeader: header andURL: URL];
      if (suba)
	[a addObjectsFromArray: suba];
    }
  
  return a;
}

+ (NSDictionary *) requestHeaderFieldsWithCookies: (NSArray *)cookies
{
  int version;
  NSString *field;
  NSHTTPCookie *ck;
  NSEnumerator *ckenum = [cookies objectEnumerator];

  if ([cookies count] == 0)
    {
      NSLog(@"NSHTTPCookie requestHeaderFieldWithCookies: empty array");
      return nil;
    }
  /* Assume these cookies all came from the same URL so we format based
     on the version of the first. */
  field = nil;
  version = [(NSHTTPCookie *)[cookies objectAtIndex: 0] version];
  if (version)
    field = @"$Version=\"1\"";
  while ((ck = [ckenum nextObject]))
    {
      NSString *str;
      str = [NSString stringWithFormat: @"%@=%@", [ck name], [ck value]];
      if (field)
	field = [field stringByAppendingFormat: @"; %@", str];
      else
	field = str;
      if (version && [ck path])
	field = [field stringByAppendingFormat: @"; $Path=\"%@\"", [ck path]];
    }

  return [NSDictionary dictionaryWithObject: field forKey: @"Cookie"];
}

- (NSString *) comment
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieComment];
}

- (NSURL *) commentURL
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieCommentURL];
}

- (void) dealloc
{
  if (this != 0)
    {
      RELEASE(this->_properties);
      NSZoneFree([self zone], this);
    }
  [super dealloc];
}

- (NSString *) domain
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieDomain];
}

- (NSDate *) expiresDate
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieExpires];
}

- (BOOL) _isValidProperty: (NSString *)prop
{
  return ([prop length]
	  && [prop rangeOfString: @"\n"].location == NSNotFound);
}

- (id) initWithProperties: (NSDictionary *)properties
{
  NSMutableDictionary *rawProps;
  if ((self = [super init]) == nil)
    return nil;

  /* Check a few values.  Based on Mac OS X tests. */
  if (![self _isValidProperty: [properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookiePath]] 
    || ![self _isValidProperty: [properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieDomain]]
    || ![self _isValidProperty: [properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieName]]
    || ![self _isValidProperty: [properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieValue]]
    )
    {
      [self release];
      return nil;
    }

  rawProps = [[properties mutableCopy] autorelease];
  if ([rawProps objectForKey: @"Created"] == nil)
    {
      NSInteger seconds;
      NSDate	*now;

      /* Round to whole seconds, so that a serialization/deserialisation
       * cycle produces an identical object whic hcan be used to eliminate
       * duplicates.
       */
      seconds = [NSDate timeIntervalSinceReferenceDate];
      now = [NSDate dateWithTimeIntervalSinceReferenceDate: seconds]; 
      [rawProps setObject: now forKey: @"Created"];
    }
  if ([rawProps objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieExpires] == nil
    || [[rawProps objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieExpires] 
		isKindOfClass: [NSDate class]] == NO)
    {
      [rawProps setObject: [NSNumber numberWithBool: YES] 
		   forKey: NSHTTPCookieDiscard];
    }

  this->_properties = [rawProps copy];
  return self;
}

- (BOOL) isSecure
{
  return [[this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieSecure] boolValue];
}

- (BOOL) isHTTPOnly
{
  return [[this->_properties objectForKey: HTTPCookieHTTPOnly] boolValue];
}

- (BOOL) isSessionOnly
{
  return [[this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieDiscard] boolValue];
}

- (NSString *) name
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieName];
}

- (NSString *) path
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookiePath];
}

- (NSArray *) portList
{
  return [[this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookiePort]
    componentsSeparatedByString: @","];
}

- (NSDictionary *) properties
{
  return this->_properties;
}

- (NSString *) value
{
  return [this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieValue];
}

- (NSUInteger) version
{
  return [[this->_properties objectForKey: NSHTTPCookieVersion] integerValue];
}

- (NSString *) description
{
  return [NSString stringWithFormat: @"<NSHTTPCookie %p: %@=%@>", self,
		   [self name], [self value]];
}

- (NSUInteger) hash
{
  return [[self properties] hash];
}

- (BOOL) isEqual: (id)other
{
  return [[other properties] isEqual: [self properties]];
}

@end

#define inrange(ch,min,max) ((ch)>=(min) && (ch)<=(max))
#define char2num(ch) \
inrange(ch,'0','9') \
? ((ch)-0x30) \
: (inrange(ch,'a','f') \
? ((ch)-0x57) : ((ch)-0x37))

typedef	struct	{
  const unsigned char	*ptr;
  unsigned	end;
  unsigned	pos;
  unsigned	lin;
  NSString	*err;
  int           opt;
  BOOL		key;
  BOOL		old;
} pldata;

/*
 *	Returns YES if there is any non-whitespace text remaining.
 */
static BOOL skipSpace(pldata *pld)
{
  unsigned char	c;

  while (pld->pos < pld->end)
    {
      c = pld->ptr[pld->pos];

      if (GS_IS_WHITESPACE(c) == NO)
	{
	  return YES;
	}
      if (c == '\n')
	{
	  pld->lin++;
	}
      pld->pos++;
    }
  pld->err = @"reached end of string";
  return NO;
}

static inline id parseQuotedString(pldata* pld)
{
  unsigned	start = ++pld->pos;
  unsigned	escaped = 0;
  unsigned	shrink = 0;
  BOOL		hex = NO;
  NSString	*obj;

  while (pld->pos < pld->end)
    {
      unsigned char	c = pld->ptr[pld->pos];

      if (escaped)
	{
	  if (escaped == 1 && c >= '0' && c <= '7')
	    {
	      escaped = 2;
	      hex = NO;
	    }
	  else if (escaped == 1 && (c == 'u' || c == 'U'))
	    {
	      escaped = 2;
	      hex = YES;
	    }
	  else if (escaped > 1)
	    {
	      if (hex && isxdigit(c))
		{
		  shrink++;
		  escaped++;
		  if (escaped == 6)
		    {
		      escaped = 0;
		    }
		}
	      else if (c >= '0' && c <= '7')
		{
		  shrink++;
		  escaped++;
		  if (escaped == 4)
		    {
		      escaped = 0;
		    }
		}
	      else
		{
		  pld->pos--;
		  escaped = 0;
		}
	    }
	  else
	    {
	      escaped = 0;
	    }
	}
      else
	{
	  if (c == '\\')
	    {
	      escaped = 1;
	      shrink++;
	    }
	  else if (c == '"')
	    {
	      break;
	    }
	}
      if (c == '\n')
	pld->lin++;
      pld->pos++;
    }
  if (pld->pos >= pld->end)
    {
      pld->err = @"reached end of string while parsing quoted string";
      return nil;
    }
  if (pld->pos - start - shrink == 0)
    {
      obj = @"";
    }
  else
    {
      unsigned	length;
      unichar	*chars;
      unichar	*temp = NULL;
      unsigned	int temp_length = 0;
      unsigned	j;
      unsigned	k;

      if (!GSToUnicode(&temp, &temp_length, &pld->ptr[start],
		       pld->pos - start, NSUTF8StringEncoding,
		       NSDefaultMallocZone(), 0))
	{
	  pld->err = @"invalid utf8 data while parsing quoted string";
	  return nil;
	}
      length = temp_length - shrink;
      chars = NSAllocateCollectable(sizeof(unichar) * length, 0);
      escaped = 0;
      hex = NO;
      for (j = 0, k = 0; j < temp_length; j++)
	{
	  unichar c = temp[j];

	  if (escaped)
	    {
	      if (escaped == 1 && c >= '0' && c <= '7')
		{
		  chars[k] = c - '0';
		  hex = NO;
		  escaped++;
		}
	      else if (escaped == 1 && (c == 'u' || c == 'U'))
		{
		  chars[k] = 0;
		  hex = YES;
		  escaped++;
		}
	      else if (escaped > 1)
		{
		  if (hex && isxdigit(c))
		    {
		      chars[k] <<= 4;
		      chars[k] |= char2num(c);
		      escaped++;
		      if (escaped == 6)
			{
			  escaped = 0;
			  k++;
			}
		    }
		  else if (c >= '0' && c <= '7')
		    {
		      chars[k] <<= 3;
		      chars[k] |= (c - '0');
		      escaped++;
		      if (escaped == 4)
			{
			  escaped = 0;
			  k++;
			}
		    }
		  else
		    {
		      escaped = 0;
		      j--;
		      k++;
		    }
		}
	      else
		{
		  escaped = 0;
		  switch (c)
		    {
		      case 'a' : chars[k] = '\a'; break;
		      case 'b' : chars[k] = '\b'; break;
		      case 't' : chars[k] = '\t'; break;
		      case 'r' : chars[k] = '\r'; break;
		      case 'n' : chars[k] = '\n'; break;
		      case 'v' : chars[k] = '\v'; break;
		      case 'f' : chars[k] = '\f'; break;
		      default  : chars[k] = c; break;
		    }
		  k++;
		}
	    }
	  else
	    {
	      chars[k] = c;
	      if (c == '\\')
		{
		  escaped = 1;
		}
	      else
		{
		  k++;
		}
	    }
	}

      NSZoneFree(NSDefaultMallocZone(), temp);
      length = k;

      obj = [NSString alloc];
      obj = [obj initWithCharactersNoCopy: chars
		 length: length
		 freeWhenDone: YES];
    }
  pld->pos++;
  return obj;
}

/* In cookies, keys are terminated by '=' and values are terminated by ';'
   or and EOL */
static inline id parseUnquotedString(pldata *pld, char endChar)
{
  unsigned	start = pld->pos;
  unsigned	i;
  unsigned	length;
  id		obj;
  unichar	*chars;

  while (pld->pos < pld->end)
    {
      if ((pld->ptr[pld->pos]) == endChar)
	break;
      pld->pos++;
    }

  length = pld->pos - start;
  chars = NSAllocateCollectable(sizeof(unichar) * length, 0);
  for (i = 0; i < length; i++)
    {
      chars[i] = pld->ptr[start + i];
    }

    {
      obj = [NSString alloc];
      obj = [obj initWithCharactersNoCopy: chars
				   length: length
			     freeWhenDone: YES];
    }
  return obj;
}

static BOOL
_setCookieKey(NSMutableDictionary *dict, NSString *key, NSString *value)
{
  if ([dict count] == 0)
    {
      /* This must be the name=value pair */
      if ([value length] == 0)
	return NO;
      [dict setObject: key forKey: NSHTTPCookieName];
      [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieValue];
      return YES;
    }
  if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"comment"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieComment];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"commenturl"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieCommentURL];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"discard"])
    [dict setObject: [NSNumber numberWithBool: YES] 
	     forKey: NSHTTPCookieDiscard];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"domain"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieDomain];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"expires"])
    {
      NSDate *expireDate;
      expireDate = [NSCalendarDate dateWithString: value
				calendarFormat: @"%a, %d-%b-%Y %I:%M:%S %Z"];
      if (expireDate)
        [dict setObject: expireDate forKey: NSHTTPCookieExpires];
    }
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"max-age"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieMaximumAge];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"originurl"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieOriginURL];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"path"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookiePath];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"port"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookiePort];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"secure"])
    [dict setObject: [NSNumber numberWithBool: YES] 
	     forKey: NSHTTPCookieSecure];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual:@"httponly"])
    [dict setObject: [NSNumber numberWithBool: YES]
             forKey: HTTPCookieHTTPOnly];
  else if ([[key lowercaseString] isEqual: @"version"])
    [dict setObject: value forKey: NSHTTPCookieVersion];
  return YES;
}

static id
GSPropertyListFromCookieFormat(NSString *string, int version)
{
  NSMutableDictionary	*dict;
  pldata		_pld;
  pldata		*pld = &_pld;
  NSData		*d;
  BOOL			moreCharacters;

  /*
   * An empty string is a nil property list.
   */
  if ([string length] == 0)
    {
      return nil;
    }

  d = [string dataUsingEncoding: NSUTF8StringEncoding];
  NSCAssert(d, @"Couldn't get utf8 data from string.");
  _pld.ptr = (unsigned char*)[d bytes];
  _pld.pos = 0;
  _pld.end = [d length];
  _pld.err = nil;
  _pld.lin = 0;
  _pld.opt = 0;
  _pld.key = NO;
  _pld.old = YES;	// OpenStep style

  dict = [[NSMutableDictionary allocWithZone: NSDefaultMallocZone()]
    initWithCapacity: 0];
  while (skipSpace(pld) == YES)
    {
      id	key;
      id	val;

      if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == '"')
	{
	  key = parseQuotedString(pld);
	}
      else
	{
	  unsigned int oldpos = pld->pos;
	  unsigned int keyvalpos = 0;
	  id keyval = parseUnquotedString(pld, ';');
	  keyvalpos = pld->pos;
	  pld->pos = oldpos;
	  key = parseUnquotedString(pld, '=');

	  // Detect value-less cookies like HTTPOnly; and Secure;
	  if ([keyval length] < [key length])
	    {
	      pld->pos = keyvalpos;
	      key = keyval;
	    }
	}
      if (key == nil)
	{
	  DESTROY(dict);
	  break;
	}
      moreCharacters = skipSpace(pld);
      if (moreCharacters == NO || pld->ptr[pld->pos] == ';')
	{
	  pld->pos++;
	  if (_setCookieKey(dict, key, @"") == NO)
	    {
	      pld->err = @"invalid cookie pair";
	      DESTROY(dict);
	    }
	  RELEASE(key);
	}
      else if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == '=')
	{
	  pld->pos++;
	  if (skipSpace(pld) == NO)
	    {
	      RELEASE(key);
	      DESTROY(dict);
	      break;
	    }
	  if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == '"')
	    {
	      val = parseQuotedString(pld);
	    }
	  else
	    {
	      val = parseUnquotedString(pld, ';');
	    }
	  if (val == nil)
	    {
	      RELEASE(key);
	      DESTROY(dict);
	      break;
	    }
          skipSpace(pld);
	  if (_setCookieKey(dict, key, val) == NO)
	    {
	      pld->err = @"invalid cookie pair";
	      DESTROY(dict);
	    }
	  RELEASE(key);
	  RELEASE(val);
	  if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == ';')
	    {
	      pld->pos++;
	    }
	  else
	    {
	      break;
	    }
	}
      else
	{
	  pld->err = @"unexpected character (wanted '=' or ';')";
	  RELEASE(key);
	  DESTROY(dict);
	  break;
	}
    }
  if (dict == nil && _pld.err != nil)
    {
      RELEASE(dict);
      [NSException raise: NSGenericException
		  format: @"Parse failed at line %d (char %d) - %@",
	_pld.lin + 1, _pld.pos + 1, _pld.err];
    }
  return AUTORELEASE(dict);
}

/* Look for the comma that separates cookies. Commas can also occur in
   date strings, like "expires", but perhaps it can occur other places.
   For instance, the key/value pair  key=value1,value2 is not really
   valid, but should we handle it anyway? Definitely we should handle the
   perfectly normal case of:

   Set-Cookie: domain=test.com; expires=Thu, 12-Sep-2109 14:58:04 GMT;
     session=foo
   Set-Cookie: bar=baz

  which gets concatenated into something like:

  Set-Cookie: domain=test.com; expires=Thu, 12-Sep-2109 14:58:04 GMT;
    session=foo,bar=baz

*/
static NSRange 
GSRangeOfCookie(NSString *string)
{
  pldata		_pld;
  pldata		*pld = &_pld;
  NSData		*d;
  NSRange               range;

  /*
   * An empty string is a nil property list.
   */
  range = NSMakeRange(NSNotFound, NSNotFound);
  if ([string length] == 0)
    {
      return range;
    }

  d = [string dataUsingEncoding: NSUTF8StringEncoding];
  NSCAssert(d, @"Couldn't get utf8 data from string.");
  _pld.ptr = (unsigned char*)[d bytes];
  _pld.pos = 0;
  _pld.end = [d length];
  _pld.err = nil;
  _pld.lin = 0;
  _pld.opt = 0;
  _pld.key = NO;
  _pld.old = YES;	// OpenStep style

  while (skipSpace(pld) == YES)
    {
      if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == ',')
	{
	  /* Look ahead for something that will tell us if this is a
	     separate cookie or not */
          unsigned saved_pos = pld->pos;
	  while (pld->ptr[pld->pos] != '=' && pld->ptr[pld->pos] != ';'
		&& pld->ptr[pld->pos] != ',' && pld->pos < pld->end )
	    pld->pos++;
	  if (pld->ptr[pld->pos] == '=')
	    {
	      /* Separate comment */
	      range = NSMakeRange(0, saved_pos-1);
	      break;
	    }
	  pld->pos = saved_pos;
	}
      pld->pos++;
    }
  if (range.location == NSNotFound)
    range = NSMakeRange(0, [string length]);

  return range;
}